How To Get Through a Yellow Light (Without Getting a Ticket)

Q: What is the standard for judging whether to continue to proceed through an intersection with a yellow light? If a police officer was going to issue a citation, what would they look for? There seems to be a whole continuum and sometimes it is hard to judge whether to make a fast stop or proceed.

A: The classic yellow light dilemma: Do I floor it or slam on the brakes? I’ve heard people say, “Red means stop, green means go, yellow means go faster.” That’s obviously not helpful advice, but in observing drivers at intersections, some people have readily accepted that flawed guidance. In this column I hope to bring a more balanced perspective to the yellow light discussion. Continue reading “How To Get Through a Yellow Light (Without Getting a Ticket)”

Bicycle Rules and Myths

Q: You state that “Target Zero is Washington’s plan to eliminate fatality and serious injury crashes by 2030,” which is laudable. When it speaks of “fatality and serious injury crashes” does that statement include those crashes where bikes are involved? I ask this because here in Bellingham there appears to be absolutely no laws affecting cyclist and their driving behavior.

A: The author of this question continues with a series of situations and statements involving cyclists. I’m going to work my way through the letter affirming laws, dispelling myths and trying to put cycling in perspective with the overall problem of fatalities on our roads. I can’t respond to all of them, but here are the highlights. Continue reading “Bicycle Rules and Myths”

Should You Get Your Speeding Ticket Deferred?

Q: I just got a speeding ticket. How do I get it deferred? Is that a good idea?

A: For some drivers, deferring a traffic infraction makes sense; for others, not so much. It depends on the kind of driver you are. I have a little quiz that can help, but first let’s explain what it means to defer a traffic infraction.

For those of you who have been given an infraction, you may recall that the ticket you received listed several options on how to respond. You can see the options in the image above. Continue reading “Should You Get Your Speeding Ticket Deferred?”

Traffic Tickets: Where The Money Goes

Q: Where does the money from a traffic ticket go?

A: To quote from a friend’s relationship status as described on Facebook, “It’s complicated.” Before I could answer this question I reviewed several charts and spreadsheets from the Washington Administrative Office of the Courts, spoke with a Budget & Judicial Impact Analyst and checked in with our local courts. Here’s the gist of what I discovered: Despite what you may have heard about police officers funding their department budget by writing traffic tickets, in Washington the money from a ticket gets divided into so many buckets that it pretty much disincentivizes any law enforcement agency from writing tickets primarily for revenue. (We’re talking about traditional traffic enforcement here; speed and red light cameras are a whole different system, and some local governments have been willing to provide actual numbers regarding the revenue that traffic cameras generate.) Local government does receives a portion of the fine from a traffic infraction, but when you see the breakdown it’s apparent that it’s not a massive revenue generator for the local police department. The goal of traffic enforcement is to reduce dangerous driver behavior, not to make money, at least for the local police department.

In a few circumstances the division of funds from a ticket depends on the kind of infraction the driver committed. For example, some of the money from a ticket for speeding in a school zone goes toward school zone safety. Aside from specially designated assessments for those types of infractions, traffic fines follow a formula of a base penalty plus a standard set of assessments. Here’s the breakdown for what the courts call a “generic” $136 traffic infraction:

Base Penalty: $48 – This is the amount you’ll find if you look up your infraction in the Washington Courts penalty schedule, which can create some confusion. If, for example, you received a ticket for tailgating (technically it’s called following too closely), you might look it up in the RCW to see if your actions fit the offense and notice that there is no fine amount listed. Digging further you might come across the Washington Courts penalty schedule and seeing $48 as the total amount for your violation think, as you look at your $136 ticket, that you got overcharged. You didn’t. The penalty schedule only includes the base penalty. This base penalty gets divided three ways: $23 is used to fund the Judicial Information System (JIS), the primary information system for courts in Washington. The remaining $25 is split between the state, getting $8, and the local government (not the police department) getting $17. The $17 gets further divided into the general fund and a crime victims fund.

The remainder of the $136 ticket gets divided into the following categories: state general fund, auto theft prevention, emergency medical services and trauma care, legislative assessment, and traumatic brain injury fund. Most of these categories are statewide, but local government receives about eight dollars from the legislative assessment. Once in the general fund, the money goes toward all kinds of government functions, hopefully including a bit for law enforcement.

I don’t mean to downplay the financial impact that a $136 ticket has on an individual. Getting a ticket is, at a minimum, financially unpleasant, and for some, a real hardship. But from a government revenue perspective it’s almost inconsequential. For example, in Whatcom County, revenue from infractions makes up about ½ of 1% of the total county budget of roughly $180 million. Even if all the infraction revenue went to the law and justice portion of the county budget (about $60 million) it would hardly make a dent.

Money from traffic infractions goes to a lot of places, but none of it ends up with the law enforcement agency that issues the infractions.

How Dark is Too Dark?

Q: How dark can window tint be on a car?

A: Maybe it’s about the heat. Maybe it’s about the style. Maybe it’s about the privacy. Whatever the reason, many people choose to tint the windows on their cars. Proponents of window tint point to several benefits; big surprise, I’ll start with safety. Window tint is a thin plastic film that goes on the inside of the glass. In a crash, this film can hold together broken glass that would otherwise fly through the car. By design, auto glass breaks into small chunks that are less likely to cause injury compared to jagged shards of glass from, say, a residential picture window, so while the tint film may help, it’s not as significant a safety feature as it first seems to be. Continue reading “How Dark is Too Dark?”

Do Red Cars Get More Speeding Tickets?

Drivers around the world have endorsed the “red cars get more tickets” theory for years. The common item missing from each version is a substantiated fact. Some of the reasons for the supposed disproportionate numbers of tickets issued to red cars seem plausible. Some are outright ridiculous.

Of the more believable explanations, one offers the idea that red cars are more noticeable due to their bright color, and catch the attention of police officers more frequently. This sounds well-founded, and I suspect most people would accept this rationale.  However, according to color experts, the most perceptible colors reside toward the middle of the color spectrum, such as yellow and bright green. Red sits on the low end of the color spectrum, making it one of the first colors to disappear from our vision in non-ideal lighting situations.

My favorite quasi-scientific myth proposes that red actually looks faster than other colors when it moves. Relying on convoluted, out-of-context “scientific” principles, proponents of this theory believe that just as an approaching siren changes its audible pitch, a red car changes its color intensity, making it appear to travel faster than its actual speed. This theory has at least two flaws. Our ears hear an audible difference in approaching and departing sounds because sound travels relatively slow. Light travels so fast that the speed of even the fastest car wouldn’t affect how we perceive the color of the car. And this maybe the most obvious problem – What about the other colors? Even if we could perceive a variation in color because of the movement of a vehicle, that alteration would affect every color, making the theory irrelevant.

The most comedic reason I’ve heard that red cars get more tickets comes from the belief that police officers have converted the pool hall game of snookers into a traffic enforcement contest. Since the game of snookers has more red balls than any other color, officers must cite a disproportionate number of red cars in order to get a high score.

A more practical approach to explaining why red cars might get more tickets involves looking at what kinds of cars get painted red. How many red sedans and mini-vans can you spot driving down the highway? Now how about red sports cars? I suspect that if lots of light-weight, high horse-power cars are red, we might see a higher percentage of red cars getting tickets.

But even that theory is suspect. Maybe red cars don’t actually receive more tickets. According to one study, red cars account for 14 percent of all cars on the road, and receive 16 percent of issued tickets. While that study does show a slight disadvantage toward red cars, the numbers of cars sampled was small enough to make a two percent difference insignificant.

Probably the best way to determine if law enforcement officers prefer to issue tickets to red cars would be to ask them. As opposed to the variety of reasons why red cars might get more tickets, officers responded unanimously, essentially stating, “We issue citations for violations, not colors.” Rather than spend time and energy trying to decide which car color will most frequently go unnoticed by traffic cops, drivers might have more success avoiding tickets if they chose to obey traffic laws.