Good Intentions, Bad Outcomes

Q. You wrote about it being a crime to host a party where minors are drinking, but isn’t it safer to have teens drink in a supervised environment where an adult can maintain some control, rather than on their own somewhere else?

A: There’s a proverb that describes the destination of roads paved with good intentions. Of course, good intentions aren’t inherently bad, but unevaluated actions don’t always take us where we hope to go. Take, for example, traffic safety commercials.

There was a time when we thought we could scare people into being better drivers. There were PSAs on TV showing gruesome crashes and drivers getting arrested, mock crash demonstrations at high schools, and dramatizations of drunk drivers, making it seem like a common behavior. For the record it’s not. Even though half of traffic fatalities in Washington involve impairment (and most of those involve impairment by alcohol), roadside surveys show that only a small percentage of drivers (about two percent) are impaired by alcohol.

It turns out that those threatening and sometimes graphic messages don’t work. And when we repeatedly show dangerous driving it normalizes it, increasing the likelihood that high-risk drivers will continue their high-risk behaviors.

What do scary traffic safety ads have to do with parents hosting parties for minors? Both are borne of good intentions. Here’s when it gets tricky, because being a parent is a sacred trust and this next part might sound like I’m trying to interfere. So I’ll defer to Socrates: “No one who either knows or believes that there is another course of action better than the one he is following will ever continue on his present course when he might choose the better”.

Applied to this context, parents are making the best decisions they can, based on the information they have. I’m going to add some additional information, and if you’re a parent that would possibly host a party for minors, maybe this will influence your course of action.

We know teenage brains haven’t fully developed the ability to make wise decisions, so if you assume that teens are going to drink alcohol, then providing a safe place to do it seems protective. But the evidence shows that it actually increases their risk of long-term harm.

Teens who drink alcohol with parental permission tend to engage in risky drinking as young adults, both in frequently and amount, compared to families that didn’t permit teens to drink. When parents supply teens with alcohol it increases future binge drinking and alcohol-related harms. As a traffic safety nerd, I’ll focus on one specific harm – impaired driving. To quote one researcher, “Binge drinking in 12th grade is a robust predictor of early adulthood DWI.” Young teens who drink with adult supervision are 56 percent more likely to drive impaired as adults.

In contrast, when parents have strict rules about alcohol, teens are more likely to postpone their first drink. And this extends into the future, too. Teens who know their parents disapprove of drinking are 30 percent less likely to drive impaired as adults.

We also shouldn’t assume that teen drinking is a given. Most high school-age kids (over 70 percent) when surveyed report not drinking in the past 30 days. But 80 percent of adults being treated for alcohol addiction began drinking as teens.

If you see a traffic safety message in Washinton today, it’ll likely show the positive behavior we want drivers to embrace. The same goes for parenting – if you want your kid to have a healthy attitude about alcohol in the future, it starts by modeling that for them today.

One Comment

(Hide Comments)
  • Merrill Gehman

    November 19, 2026 / at 11:59 am Reply

    Good article Doug

Leave a reply

Previous Post

Next Post

Loading Next Post...
Sign In/Sign Up Sidebar Search Trending
Loading

Signing-in 3 seconds...

Signing-up 3 seconds...